Celebrity Homes

Carly Simon House: The Martha’s Vineyard Estate That Grew From a 1969 Cabin

By Daniel Harper

In this article

Carly Simon lives year-round on Martha’s Vineyard. The Carly Simon house there sits on a wooded estate in the town of Tisbury and grew out of a small cabin James Taylor built in 1969. It has been her main home for decades. Her only other well-documented property, a West Village co-op in Manhattan, took more than five years to sell before it finally went for close to $2.3 million in 2013.

Tisbury, MA

Built as a cabin in 196925 wooded acres (2023)Year-round home

The Martha’s Vineyard property has been the singer’s base since her years with James Taylor.

The Carly Simon House on Martha’s Vineyard

The estate started small. Showing journalist Nigel Farndale old photos of the building site in 2010, Simon said Taylor built the house in 1969, and that it was then “just a cabin in the wood” where the couple slept on a pull-out couch. Simon had spent childhood summers on the island with her family, and Taylor had his own ties to it, so the Vineyard became their shared base.

Over the following decades the cabin turned into a compound. By Farndale’s 2010 visit it had a recording studio, a library, a tennis court and a 45-foot watchtower climbed by a nautical-style spiral staircase. A 2023 profile in Cape Cod and the Islands magazine lists a swimming pool, a separate office, a second house where her son Ben Taylor lives, and a treehouse built when her grandson was small.

The land also carries a menagerie: miniature ponies, goats, sheep and donkeys, according to the same 2023 profile. Simon’s peonies grow there in such numbers that photos of them ended up printed on a line of scarves she designed. Her childhood friend Tamara Weiss calls the place Hidden Star Hill and describes the interior as warm and shabby chic.

The Vineyard estate at a glance

TownTisbury, Martha’s Vineyard
OriginCabin built by James Taylor, 1969
Land25 acres (2023) / 40 acres (2010 report)
Extra buildingsStudio, office, son’s house, treehouse, watchtower
GroundsPool, tennis court, peony gardens
AnimalsPonies, goats, sheep, donkeys

Reports differ on the size. The Real Deal described a 40-acre estate in 2010, while the 2023 magazine profile puts it at 25 wooded acres. No sale or subdivision has been reported, so the gap may simply come down to different sources or how the land is counted.

Life Inside the Tisbury Home

The house has been part of Simon’s work as well as her private life. The 1983 music video for “You Know What to Do” was filmed there. In her interview with Farndale, she claimed the house was haunted: guests in the spare bedroom supposedly keep hearing the same conversation about a record deal.

The main room Farndale described held a baby grand piano, a chessboard and an acoustic guitar leaning on a rocking chair, with photos of friends Jackie Onassis and Bill Clinton on display. He noted there were no photos of Taylor, even though the house Taylor started still shapes her life there.

As of the 2023 profile, Simon shares the house with Richard Koehler, a surgeon and her partner of nearly two decades, along with her cavapoo, Aja. She has thought about downsizing over the years but told the magazine she can’t bear to leave the place or its memories.

The West Village Co-op She Sold in 2013

For a long stretch, Simon also kept a foot in New York City, where she was raised in the Riverdale section of the Bronx. The Real Deal reported that she bought a two-bedroom, two-bathroom duplex co-op in the West Village in early 2004 for about $1.2 million. The apartment had two wood-burning fireplaces, wide-plank floors and exposed brick.

Selling it took years. She first listed the duplex in 2008 at roughly $3.9 million, then cut the asking price to $2.98 million two years later. A 2012 relisting started at $2.8 million and dropped to $2.5 million before the listing was pulled, and a 2013 relisting came down to about $2.46 million. In November 2013, The Real Deal reported that it had sold for close to $2.3 million. That sale price was about $1.1 million more than she paid, but around $1.6 million below her first asking price.

The West Village co-op, start to finish

  1. 2004Buys the West Village duplex ~$1.2M
  2. 2008First listed for sale ~$3.9M
  3. 2010Asking price cut $2.98M
  4. 2012Relisted, then cut before being pulled $2.5M
  5. 2013Sold ~$2.3M

Once the apartment sold, Simon no longer had a city base on record. The Real Deal reported in 2010 that she was already spending most of her time on Martha’s Vineyard. The 2023 profile describes a life lived almost entirely on the island, where New York, Los Angeles and London had long since faded from her routine.

Sources

Written by

Daniel Harper

Daniel Harper is the byline on Homes Archives, covering what notable houses cost, who designed them and how they changed hands. Articles are built from public property records, archived listings and published reporting, and flag any figure that is an estimate rather than a matter of record. The name is a pen name: the site is written and edited by two people.

Who writesA pen name. The site is written and edited by two people.
SourcesPublic property records, listings and published reporting.
EstimatesAny figure that is an estimate is labelled in the article.

Leave a Comment

Keep reading

All Celebrity Homes

Not sure who to read next?

Jump straight into a random celebrity house tour.

Surprise me