Kelly Killoren Bensimon has spent most of her adult life in one Manhattan apartment: a two-story co-op in the Police Building, the former New York City Police Headquarters on the edge of Little Italy and Nolita. She bought it in the 1990s with her then-husband, fashion photographer Gilles Bensimon, raised their two daughters there, and in March 2025 put it on the market for $8,995,000, acting as her own listing agent at Douglas Elliman.
Anyone searching for the Kelly Bensimon house may also come across her second address: the couple built a shingle-style beach house in East Hampton, which she sold in 2012 after a year of price cuts that took the asking price from $12 million to $5.5 million.
$8.995M
Listed March 20253 bedroomsThe Police Building
Asking price for the Little Italy co-op the Bensimons bought in the 1990s, not a sale price.
The Kelly Bensimon House in the Police Building
The building itself is the story. Completed in the early 1900s, it served as New York’s police headquarters from 1909 to 1973, which is where the “Police Building” nickname comes from. Ehrenkrantz Eckstut & Kuhn Architects converted it into luxury apartments in 1988, a few years before the Bensimons moved in.
According to the 2025 listing described by People, the unit has three bedrooms, each with its own bathroom, spread over two floors of about 2,600 square feet. The selling points she highlighted were 16-foot ceilings, an entry foyer and a large arched window. “First, it’s like a home because there’s so much space,” she told Us Weekly, adding that each family member had their own bedroom.
The Police Building co-op at a glance
A long road to selling
The 2025 listing was not the first attempt to move the apartment. In 2013, The Real Deal reported it was offered for rent at $20,000 a month, and noted the unit was in Gilles Bensimon’s name rather than hers. Four years later, when the former “Real Housewives of New York City” cast member joined Dolly Lenz Real Estate as a broker, The Real Deal reported her first listing would be this same co-op, at around $10 million.
Her stated reason in 2025 was the empty nest. “My girls have left the nest, and it’s time for me to celebrate my new life,” she told Us Weekly, describing the move as a downsize. As of the latest reports we found, no closed sale or new home has been disclosed. She still works as a Douglas Elliman agent and listings show she has since represented other apartments in the same building.
The East Hampton Beach House
The Hamptons property started with land. Gilles Bensimon bought the parcel in East Hampton for $750,000 in 1994, according to a Wall Street Journal report cited in later coverage, and the couple built a shingle-clad beach house there in 1998. The Real Deal described it as about 5,800 square feet with five bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms, with vaulted ceilings and rustic wood beams, a deck and a heated pool. Reports put the lot at between roughly 1.2 and 1.5 acres.
The couple divorced in 2007, and it was Kelly who eventually sold the house. When she listed it in January 2012, the $12 million ask did not hold. The price fell to $8 million in February, to just under $7 million by July and finally to $5.5 million. Patch, citing the New York Daily News, reported the deal closed in late November 2012 for $5.75 million, slightly above that last ask; other reports put the figure at about $5.76 million.
East Hampton: from land to sale
- 1994Gilles Bensimon buys the land $750K
- 1998The couple builds a shingle-style beach house
- Jan 2012Listed for sale $12M
- Feb 2012First price cut $8M
- Jul 2012Cut again $6.99M
- Nov 2012Sale closes after a final ask of $5.5M $5.75M
The buyers, a New York City couple who collect modern art and design, later added a pool house and hired Southampton designer Timothy Godbold to gut the kitchen and primary bathroom. The Cool Hunter reported in 2022 that the expanded house now has six bedrooms, six bathrooms and about 7,300 square feet. For a sense of how that stretch of the Hamptons compares, see Gwyneth Paltrow’s Hamptons home and Richard Gere’s former estate.
Sources
- People via AOL (March 2025): 2025 listing price, size, bedrooms, features, building history and quotes.
- The Real Deal (May 2013): $20,000-a-month rental listing and ownership in Gilles Bensimon’s name.
- The Real Deal (December 2017): her move into brokerage and plan to list the co-op at about $10 million.
- The Real Deal (October 2012): East Hampton size, layout, price cuts and contract.
- East Hampton Patch (December 2012): $5.75 million sale and closing date.
- The Cool Hunter (April 2022): 1998 construction, the buyers and the later renovation.




