Jared Fogle, the former Subway spokesman, lived in Zionsville, Indiana, an affluent Boone County suburb north of Indianapolis. That is the home federal agents searched on July 7, 2015, and records from the Boone County treasurer’s office, cited by Fox 13 at the time, showed Fogle as its owner. A second property tied to him, a modest Indianapolis house he financed for the head of his charity, ended up in a court-ordered sheriff’s sale in 2016.
No reliable outlet has published a purchase price, square footage or sale record for the Zionsville home. Figures for it that circulate online have no documented source, so they are left out here.
Fogle’s two Indiana properties on record
- Mar 2014Land contract on an Indianapolis house with Russell Taylor $191,000
- May 2015Taylor’s monthly payments stop, per Fogle’s lawsuit
- Jul 2015FBI and Indiana State Police search the Zionsville home
- Aug 2015Fogle sues Taylor and files for foreclosure
- May 2016Indianapolis house goes to a court-ordered sheriff’s sale
The Zionsville Home
Fogle, born in Indianapolis in 1977 and a graduate of the city’s North Central High School and Indiana University Bloomington, stayed in central Indiana after Subway made him a national face in 2000. He married Kathleen (Katie) McLaughlin in July 2010, and by 2015 the couple had two young children, born in 2011 and 2013.
The house became national news on the morning of July 7, 2015. Investigators arrived around 6:30 a.m., the Indianapolis Business Journal reported, and NBC News described agents carrying a computer and other electronics to an evidence truck in the driveway. Shortly after noon Fogle left in a car with his lawyer, Ron Elberger, who said his client had not been arrested or charged and was cooperating with law enforcement. The search grew out of the federal case against Russell Taylor, the former executive director of The Jared Foundation, who had been arrested about two months earlier.
In August 2015 Fogle agreed to plead guilty to federal child-pornography charges and to traveling to engage in illicit sexual conduct with a minor, and he was sentenced that November. His divorce from Katie was finalized on November 16, 2015, with Fogle agreeing to pay her $7 million, according to Wikipedia’s summary of the court record. Reporting from the period does not say who kept the Zionsville house or whether it was later sold. The 2023 Investigation Discovery docuseries Jared From Subway: Catching a Monster, streaming on discovery+, revisits the raid on the house.
About online “mansion” figures
Aggregator pages about the Jared Fogle house often attach a dollar value or square footage to the Zionsville property. None of the news coverage of the 2015 search, the plea or the divorce gives those numbers, so treat them as unverified.
Jared Fogle House in Indianapolis: The Taylor Property
The second property is the one that ended up in court. According to the Indianapolis Business Journal, Fogle made a $191,000 personal loan toward a house in Indianapolis for Taylor under a land contract dated March 10, 2014. Taylor was to pay $850 a month and had allegedly paid nothing since May 2015, leaving about $184,400 owed by mid-August. Taylor had signed the home over to his estranged wife, Angela, on June 2, 2015, and Fogle’s suit named both of them.
The records were not tidy. The IBJ found that Marion County listed Taylor buying the house from another individual for $192,000 on March 19, 2014, with no mention of Fogle, and that it was listed for sale at $187,000. WRTV later described it as Fogle’s investment property, sold to Taylor on the land contract, and reported that Fogle filed for foreclosure on August 26, 2015.
Taylor was sentenced to 27 years in federal prison in December 2015. Court documents said some of the material in his case was recorded inside that house. By May 2016 it had sat empty for months, with mold and a need for major repairs, WRTV reported. Marion County Superior Court appointed Key Auctioneers, working for the court rather than for Fogle, to sell it to the highest bidder at a sheriff’s sale on May 25, 2016. No final price has been reported.
Zionsville vs. Indianapolis
Zionsville
Family home
Owned by Fogle in 2015
- Searched July 7, 2015
- No price on record
Indianapolis
$191,000
Land contract, March 2014
- Listed at $187,000 in 2015
- Sheriff’s sale May 2016
Where Does Jared Fogle Live Now?
Fogle was sentenced to 15 years and eight months in federal prison, plus lifetime supervised release, and was moved in December 2015 to the Federal Correctional Institution Englewood, near Littleton in Jefferson County, Colorado. He was also ordered to forfeit $50,000 and pay $1.4 million in restitution. As of the latest reports, he remains in federal custody.
Sources
- NBC News (July 2015): the search of the Zionsville home and Ron Elberger’s statement.
- Fox 13 (July 2015): Boone County treasurer records showing Fogle owned the Zionsville property.
- Indianapolis Business Journal (August 2015): the $191,000 land contract, Marion County records and lawsuit.
- WRTV (May 2016): the foreclosure, the condition of the Indianapolis house and the sheriff’s sale.
- Global News (March 2023): the Investigation Discovery docuseries and its account of the Zionsville raid.
- Wikipedia: biography, marriage, divorce terms, sentence and prison facility.
