Taylor Hicks has two homes worth knowing about, and neither of them is the mansion the internet keeps attaching to his name. He lives in Germantown, a historic neighbourhood just north of downtown Nashville, in a house that became briefly and unhappily newsworthy when a tornado tore through the area in March 2020. He also owns waterfront property on Guntersville Lake in northern Alabama, bought after he won American Idol, which he visits only a couple of times a year.
No purchase price has been published for either, and that absence is worth stating up front rather than filling it with a guess. What follows is what is actually documented about both properties, why the Alabama land matters more to him than its size suggests, and why several widely circulated claims about a Calabasas retreat, a Henderson, Nevada bungalow, or a three-acre Birmingham estate should be set aside.
Taylor Hicks’ Homes at a Glance
| Nashville Home | Guntersville Lake Property | |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Germantown, Nashville, Tennessee | Goose Pond Island, Lake Guntersville, Alabama |
| Type | Primary residence | Second home/waterfront retreat |
| Community | Historic nineteenth-century neighbourhood, walking distance to Nashville’s music infrastructure | The Oaks, a gated lakeside community |
| Acquired | Not published; resident for many years before 2020 | After his 2006 American Idol win |
| Purchase price | Not published | Not published |
| Size / square footage | Not published | Not published |
| How often he’s there | Primary base; on record living there since at least 2020 | By his own account, once or twice a year |
| Notable history | Struck by an EF3 tornado on 2 March 2020 | Bought specifically for access to Guntersville’s bass fishing |
Who is Taylor Hicks?
Taylor Hicks is an American singer born in Birmingham, Alabama, who won the fifth season of American Idol in 2006. Prematurely grey in his twenties and rooted in soul and blues rather than pop, he was an unusual winner for the show, and his fanbase adopted the name Soul Patrol.
Since then he has worked steadily as a touring performer rather than a chart act, with long runs in Las Vegas and a schedule built around live dates, most of them in the South and around Nashville. He also co-owns Saw’s Juke Joint, a barbecue-and-live-music spot in Birmingham’s Crestline neighbourhood that he opened in 2011 under a different name before rebranding it the following year with pitmaster Mike Wilson, which keeps him tied to his home state commercially as well as personally.
That career shape explains his property choices. A musician who works constantly on the road, mostly regionally, needs a base in a music city and somewhere to go when the calendar clears. He has one of each.
The Nashville house in Germantown
Hicks has lived in Nashville for many years and owns a home in Germantown, one of the city’s oldest neighbourhoods, sitting just north of the downtown core. It is a district of nineteenth-century brick housing and converted industrial buildings that has become one of Nashville’s more desirable addresses, and it is within walking distance of much of the city’s working music infrastructure.
The house entered the public record in the worst possible way. On the night of 2 March 2020, a tornado that reached EF3 intensity moved through north Nashville and directly through Germantown, part of an outbreak that killed around two dozen people across central Tennessee.
Hicks was at home, and his account of how he rode it out varies slightly depending on which interview you read: he told one Nashville TV station he heard “the train sound and the vibration” and took cover in a closet, while another outlet has him describing large debris carried a hundred feet into the air and sheltering in a crawl space in his garage. The two versions aren’t necessarily in conflict — a person moving through a house mid-storm can end up in more than one spot — but it’s worth flagging rather than presenting either detail as the single settled account.
What both interviews agree on is the scale of what happened around him: he said his own house took some damage, while homes and businesses roughly a hundred yards away were levelled outright. In the days afterwards he filmed a walk through the damaged streets around him.
Local outlets covering the storm identified him straightforwardly as a Germantown resident, which is the clearest confirmation available that Nashville is where he actually lives rather than merely works. Nashville has drawn a great many performers to live full time as well as record, from Reese Witherspoon to a long list of working musicians.
The Guntersville Lake property in Alabama
After winning American Idol, Hicks bought waterfront property on Goose Pond Island, in a gated lakeside community called The Oaks on Lake Guntersville in northern Alabama. The lake is a 69,000-acre reservoir created by the Tennessee Valley Authority along a 75-mile stretch of the Tennessee River, and it is the largest body of water in the state.
The community offers the things that make a lake property usable rather than ornamental. Documented features of The Oaks include:
- Two marinas for lake access
- A dedicated boat launch
- A community clubhouse
- Gated, controlled access
- Open water views of Lake Guntersville
No comparable list exists for the Nashville house, since its features and layout have never been detailed publicly. Hicks has been direct about why he bought at Guntersville, and it is not about the house. He came to know the lake during years of touring the Southeast, and he has spoken about the bass fishing on Guntersville, which is genuinely famous among anglers, in terms considerably warmer than he uses for most things.
He has also been honest about how little he gets to use it. By his own account, his schedule limits him to a visit once or twice a year, though he has described splitting his time more broadly between Nashville, Birmingham and the Gulf Coast, where he performs at venues like the Flora-Bama, and says he gets back to the Birmingham area two or three times a month. That is a reasonable description of a great many second homes, and it is more candid than the usual celebrity account of a retreat.
Claims that do not hold up
Three assertions circulate widely and should be treated with care. One is that Hicks lives in Calabasas, California. Another is that he settled in Henderson, a Las Vegas suburb, in a modest single-family home somewhere in the $500,000 to $800,000 range. The third is that his home is an estate of roughly 5,200 square feet on nearly three acres outside Birmingham, Alabama.
None of the three appears in property records, a listing, or any mainstream reporting, and they don’t even agree with each other. Each one, though, seems to trace back to a real fact that got stretched past what it actually supports. Birmingham is where he was born, though the family moved to the suburb of Hoover when he was eight and still has ties there — proximity to the truth, not evidence of a specific estate. The Nevada connection has a similar shape: Hicks auditioned for American Idol in Las Vegas, and from 2012 to 2014 he held residencies at Bally’s Las Vegas and then the larger Paris Las Vegas, making him the first Idol winner to land a long-term Vegas booking.
Two years on a Strip stage is the kind of detail that’s easy for a content mill to round up into “lives in Nevada,” but a performing contract at a casino is not a residence, and no property record anywhere ties him to Henderson or any other Las Vegas suburb. Calabasas has no such originating fact at all; it appears to be a guess based on where television people are assumed to live. Plausibility is not evidence, and none of the three claims is supported here.
Where does Taylor Hicks live now?
Nashville, Tennessee, in the Germantown neighbourhood.
This is well supported by the standards that matter. He was identified as a Germantown resident by Tennessee news outlets covering the 2020 tornado; he gave first-hand accounts from inside the house during the storm, and his touring schedule has been centred on Nashville and the surrounding region for years. The Encyclopedia of Alabama, a reference source with no reason to favour one state’s claim on him over another, states plainly that he currently resides in Nashville, and he has continued to turn up there in recent years, including a debut at the Grand Ole Opry in June 2023. Nothing in reliable reporting since suggests he has moved.
He retains substantial ties to Alabama, through the lake property, through Saw’s Juke Joint, and through family and hometown connections. Those ties are real, and they are why he is often described as an Alabama resident. But spending part of the year somewhere and running a business there is not the same as living there, and the evidence for Nashville as his home is considerably stronger. Other Nashville-based performers, including Jelly Roll, have followed the same pattern of keeping a working base in the city while remaining identified with somewhere else.
What is not known!
Neither property has a published purchase price, square footage, or listing history, and no interior photographs of either have been released through a real-estate channel. That is unremarkable. Hicks won a talent show two decades ago and has worked as a mid-level touring act since; he is not the kind of buyer whose transactions get written up by property reporters, and he has not put either home on the market.
There is one further loose thread worth naming rather than resolving. In a 2014 interview, Hicks mentioned owning a handful of rental properties, joking that people got a kick out of having him as a landlord. Neither the number, the type, nor the location of these was specified, and nothing since has updated that detail, so it’s included here as something he has said about himself rather than as a documented fact about what he currently owns.
Any article offering a precise value for the Taylor Hicks house is producing it from a net-worth estimate rather than from a record.
Sources
- The Tennessee Star on his Germantown residence and his account of the March 2020 tornado.
- TooFab on where he sheltered and what he saw from the house.
- The Land Report on the Goose Pond Island property at Lake Guntersville, the community’s facilities, and his own comments on why he bought there.
- Wikipedia for the tornado’s intensity and path through Germantown, cross-checked against contemporaneous news coverage.
- Encyclopedia of Alabama confirming his current Nashville residence, his Birmingham birth and Hoover upbringing, and the history of his restaurant venture.
- HooverSun.com on his time split between Nashville, Birmingham, and the Gulf Coast.
1 thought on “Taylor Hicks House: His Nashville Home and Alabama Lake Property”